I meant to write this last night when our interaction left me heartbroken in ways I should have predicted. I’m not sure how many more times I can withstand all the times you break me down just to build me up again. I’ve already told you how my friends are my family, a love I expressed so sincerely that you called me an angel. I shook my head, vehemently, because I’ve never been described as someone remotely seraphic or even innocent before.
“It’s not that I’m that good of a person,” I said, “It’s that they’re all that incredible.”
I can’t believe how lucky I am to live with the love that I’ve found, to know that I am unconditionally understood when my own blood bullies me into believing I’m badly blemished. But you stare at me with this look in your eyes, like you can’t believe the love that you’ve found, and I never return your gaze or glance at the mirror behind you because I’m afraid to see what’s written on my face in response.
Every time I’m convinced I know how you feel about me and choose to be braver to compensate for the courage you lack, or keep stifled with a self-control I can’t seem to access, you suddenly grow cold and speak to me in a way that makes me feel uncertain. I know you well enough to have moved past my former stage of insecurity, but I hate this awkward two-step you’ve caught me in when you know full-well I can’t dance. I take a couple steps forward, you take three steps back. I respond accordingly, after lengthy talks with myself to give you up, when you pull me closer until my resolve crumbles and I’m left relying on your grip to stand.
My friends, who are forever rooting for me to find love, would hate you interminably for what you said the other day. They’re left in puzzled anticipation, inquiring daily, “So what happens next?”
I shrug coyly, but the truth is that my response is a calculated silence because I don’t want them to stop rooting for you. I can’t come to a conclusion about whether the cold persona you revert to is a rare glimpse of the real you or if the man that observes me so intently is who you really are. I hesitantly opened up to you about the traumatic experience I had in the taxi when I was convinced the driver had bad intentions and I prayed with the entirety of my being for the heavens to alter my fate. My whole body trembled as I relived my ordeal and I was shocked to see you didn’t take me seriously at all. You assessed the situation too pragmatically, mansplaining that my instincts had misled me to believe in a bigger danger and advising that I avoid unsavory situations by heading home before dawn.
Then you said, “You shouldn’t feel afraid – if you ever fall victim to unwarranted advances, all you have to do is pull up your sleeves to reveal your tattoos and scare them off.”
My ears rang with your words for the rest of the day, well into the night, and echoed in the dawn of the following morning. I felt too numb to feel hurt, instead feeling like I had finally received the answer I was too afraid to seek. I’ve always wondered about your perception of me – you’re someone so wholesome and unblemished while I wear my heart and my scars and my stories on my sleeve for everyone to see. My family members insist that my ink is a revelation of my lack of self-love, that each new piece is a form of mutilation because I hate myself so much. I wondered if that’s how you view me too, especially when you asked if I don’t regret the fact that I’ll never see the skin beneath the ink in my lifetime again.
The truth is, my tattoos are a form of armor, so I can’t disagree with the tactic you proposed. I’ve felt vulnerable for most of my life; objectified by the Korean practice of unfiltered criticism about my body, oversaturated with impossible standards perpetuated by glossy teen magazines, and subjected to offhanded comments by the men who’ve seen me naked – including one particularly cruel golden-eyed monster who publicly compared my flat, yellow planes to a pancake and put me off my favorite breakfast food until I realized “FUCK HIM” and ate a whole stack while half-drunk off whiskey and self-reclaimed power.
I told you that every time I get a new piece, I feel as though I am sustaining this trajectory of self-empowerment. Each body part I so harshly criticized prior suddenly becomes beautiful when viewed in this new light; less flawed and more a vehicle lovingly adorned with art. You smiled and told me that in that case, I should never stop accumulating more pieces and I felt impossibly seen by someone who had told me just mere moments before that my skin was akin to a weapon.
I told him what you said, partially unfiltered by painkillers and partially overwhelmed by the unending loop of repeating your callous words in my head. He listened in a way you never seem to, more receptive to my heartache than how your face visibly tightens when I share less than angelic confessions with you. He told me you must have been joking, especially when he witnessed the aftermath of my trauma in my trembling hands and took it upon himself to make sure I made it home safely every night following that incident.
But I know you and I know you were sincere, that you shrugged off my fear as another way in which I was over-reacting or being hyper-sensitive; another trapping of the emotional woman. I stubbornly insisted, remembering how to speak in your absence, about how my fear wasn’t a joking matter nonetheless. I informed him about a terror he’s lucky enough to never experience; having been blessed with being born as a man. I spoke about how he’ll never know how it feels when all the hairs on every inch of your body is raised in high alert and your blood is screaming in your ears to get yourself the fuck out of there.
I said, “Even if he was kidding, I don’t understand how anyone could see me shaking and decide that a joke is the appropriate way to respond.”
I said, “Even if you think he was kidding, I don’t understand how anyone could interpret what he said as a joke when he followed up his statement with – Well, I know you so I understand your tattoos but anyone else would find them scary.”
And even now, as I write this, I imagine how my friends would react to me falling for a person who could say something like that about me – someone so cherished and protected and fully seen by them, someone so flawlessly and fully beautiful in their eyes – How could I give my heart away to anyone who could look at me and possibly think otherwise?
Then today, you traced your finger around the circle on my shoulder and I blushed as I had to explain the Neil Gaiman tattoo in which I had to look you in the eyes and call myself beautiful. I felt instantly vulnerable, as if my skin was unmarred and all my formidable ink had been washed away. I felt conflicted about how someone, who just days before had likened my tattoos to terrifying trenches, could instantly cross that divide to disarm me so carelessly.
You spent the day asking about each piece in earnest, marking your progress across the map of my skin, dog-earing the pages of each story I shared with you as your eyes widened in rapt absorption. You confessed that since the day we met, you’ve had to fight the urge to ask me about each and every single one with a building curiosity that has now become impossible to suppress. I laughed and told you I have a novel written about each one and that a week would be insufficient to explain them all to you. Then we both paused, realizing that today marks exactly one week before I leave, and you said quietly: “Time goes by too quickly, doesn’t it?”
You glanced down and saw my fists were balled when you brushed the part of my spine that’s still swollen with unresolved tension and said, almost to yourself: “I wish you weren’t in pain anymore,” almost your parting wish, almost a prayer, and I felt my heart tighten with that all-too-familiar ache that’s attributable only to you.
You continued to press along my spine, taking inventory and asking if my swollen disc or my troublesome lower back hurt more. It became a game, “Which hurts more – your leg or your spine?” “Your right shoulder blade or your left herniated disc?” “Your back tattoo or your ruptured cyst?” “Your body or your heart?”
How could I tell you that none of the physical ailments you handle in your hands compare to the ways in which you unwind me with your words?
It’s so wrong how you hurt me so deeply, but I still can’t help but wish that you liked me every time the clock chimes 11:11.
Every time I want you to care, you’re never there. But each time I lose my balance, you anticipate the fall before it happens.
I reread everything I’ve written about you in an effort to better understand what you might be thinking, to elucidate if it’ll be a mistake to share with you how I’m feeling. I’ve uncovered an unmistakable pattern in which you draw closer when I’m full of light and laughing but whenever I make the mistake of showing you how much I’m struggling, you pull back and treat me with a kind of indifference I’m convinced couldn’t be disingenuous. I wish you would exhibit the kind of emotional concern you express over the state of my broken body; always reaching out instinctively when my weak leg buckles and I lose my footing. But you habitually retreat into yourself whenever I show any weakness, in the same way you glow with pride when I exhibit signs of strength.
I’m not a tattooed harpy and I’m definitely no angel. It’s impossible for me to smile for you every time you see me and I find myself missing the person you used to be when I would cry openly in front of you. Your star sign proclaims you’re someone destructively overprotective but I couldn’t find that to be less true. I don’t sense any darkness in you, it’s a kind of nuance you lack having grown up in a small country town with unquestioned roots and no desire to rebel or run away or differentiate yourself from the demands of your daily existence.
If I could separate my sea from my fire, if I could split my smiles from my tears, if I could shed my skin from my ink; it’s something I would consider doing for you. But such a stupid thought is nothing more than a fleeting contemplation – I am too wholly loved to ever consider being romanced only partially.
You are nothing more than someone I almost loved.